The INTERNATIONAL GEOGRAPHY OLYMPIAD (iGeo)



What is iGeo?

The Next iGeo

Previous iGeos &
past questions


Test Guidelines

Statutes

National Competitions

What is geography?

Sponsors

Contact
     Sue Lomas
     Sueguides@hotmail.co.uk

Website Sponsor:

The 2002 iGeo - Durban, South Africa

"Skyview"                                                                                                                                     
Durban, South Africa - 2002 iGeo

Evaluation

These comments have been copied verbatim in response to three questions. Team leaders facilitated discussion amongst participants. All comments have been included regardless of repetition.

  • What were the strengths of the event?
    • The teams were able to exchange cultural experiences
    • The tasks were rich in nature that we didn't feel too much pressure on the team members
    • The tasks were different from what we have in our country and gave us new insights on learning and assessing geography
    • There was an emphasis on integrated geography and pure theory was not the object of the tasks
    • The event was a challenge to both the participating students and the assessing teachers
    • Well organized
    • Building of the team relationships
    • Team work of the organizers
    • Knowledge and experience building
    • Various fields of study
    • Gifts
    • Encouragement to the teams by organizers
    • The competition was not only knowledge based but has the fieldwork as well where students can show their skills
    • Cultural exchange
    • The possibility to see the places in the surroundings what usually tourists do not see
    • Helpful and kind organizing committee
    • Accommodation near the ocean
    • Good experience in geography
    • Communication with people
    • Living all together
    • Frequent meeting opportunities
    • Team work of students and team leaders as well
    • Skills based student work
    • Organisational care
    • Many nations participating
    • Interesting tasks
    • Great experiences
    • Good interactions
    • A good atmosphere and it was a lot of fun meeting everybody
    • The cultural evening was very nice - we enjoyed it!
    • The field work was very interesting
    • Dorms for students: stimulates contacts
    • Fieldwork exercises: interesting and stimulating issues of connection between excursions and exercises
    • Marvelous atmosphere
    • Enthusiasm of competent organizers
    • Cultural evening
    • Country presentations
    • Good questions
    • Excellent fieldwork
    • Criteria for assessing
    • Friendship and tolerance
    • Excursion to agricultural area
    • Timetable was done perfect
    • Organisation
    • Perfect competition leaders
    • Nice and co-operative national teams and leaders
  • What were the weaknesses of the event?
    • The schedule was very tight, we had little time to get acquainted with each other and get some rest
    • Translation lacking
    • Time constraints
    • The problems (tasks?) have to be more detailed
    • As the students write in their mother tongue the judging could be subjective and other judges can not really read it through
    • Teacher were too much involved in helping students
    • The programme of the event was overcrowded
    • There weren't enough excursions for sightseeing
    • Museums weren't visited
    • National self-evaluation of team works
    • Absence of cross-evaluations
    • Unclear project determination
    • Poor accommodation
    • A lot of programme - not enough free time
    • No impression of Durban (accommodation site too far away)
    • We didn't see South Africa!
    • Some of the exams were silly? and some didn't show any geographical knowledge
    • Quiz required mostly knowledge and little skills
    • Absence of written text
    • Overloaded programme
    • Absence of coordinating body (not the fault of the SA organizers but responsibility of the IGU)
  • How could the event be improved?
    • With a little more free time
    • With a playground for sport events
    • With a cultural evening of SA dances
    • With an excursion more further from Durban - whole day
    • More countries to participate, spread more evenly over the continents
    • More even balance between individual and team work
    • Include written test with emphasis on geographical skills
    • Ask students from the organizing country to assist the teams (1 per team) - this enables you to organize separate activities for team leaders - discuss national competition, developments in geography education
    • Tell students the criteria for assessment beforehand
    • Independent assessors - more detailed marking scheme
    • Provide more resource material for the decision making exercises
    • The accommodation!
    • A day trip
    • All in all it was great fun!
    • One free afternoon in the city for visit
    • More teams should be invited
    • Independent assessment committee should be created
    • There must be one language for solving problems. Students have to know the language to be able to communicate with others anyway
    • Competition has to be for individual students
    • Time consciousness
    • Translation of languages
    • Trophy
    • Putting together a set of rules for the competition and making them available and applicable in all countries. (These should be the same regulations for all competitions regardless of the organizing country)

(c) www.geoolympiad.org | Hosted by the Department of Geography, National Taiwan Normal University | Site Admin